• CanAmericaNews
  • Posts
  • The Salmon Saga: Farmed vs Wild, or “How to Lose Friends and Annoy Fishermen”

The Salmon Saga: Farmed vs Wild, or “How to Lose Friends and Annoy Fishermen”

Or: How to Pick Your Fish Without Losing Your Mind (or Your Wallet)By Javier Clarkson

In partnership with

Picture this: You’re standing in the seafood aisle, squinting at two hunks of pink fish. One claims to be “wild, free, and probably has a better social life than you.” The other is “farmed,” which, let’s be honest, sounds like it spent its life watching reruns of The Bachelor in a net pen. Welcome to the great salmon standoff-the only battle where the loser is always your wallet. But first, a word from our sponsor:

Find out why 1M+ professionals read Superhuman AI daily.

In 2 years you will be working for AI

Or an AI will be working for you

Here's how you can future-proof yourself:

  1. Join the Superhuman AI newsletter – read by 1M+ people at top companies

  2. Master AI tools, tutorials, and news in just 3 minutes a day

  3. Become 10X more productive using AI

Join 1,000,000+ pros at companies like Google, Meta, and Amazon that are using AI to get ahead.

Farming Salmon: The Aquatic Factory Reset

Farmed salmon are raised in what can only be described as the fish equivalent of a high-rise condo complex. They start life in freshwater tanks, then graduate to sea cages-sort of like moving from a playpen to a swimming pool, only with more sea lice and less fun. This process takes three years, which is longer than most reality TV marriages, and requires enough infrastructure to make Elon Musk weep into his rocket fuel. Replacing U.S. salmon imports with land-based farms would cost $26 billion, or roughly the GDP of a small nation-or a large Kardashian wedding.

Wild Salmon: The Original Free-Range Hipster

Wild salmon, meanwhile, are caught by people in boats who insist on wearing waders and talking about “the good old days.” Techniques range from drift fishing (standing in a river, getting wet, catching nothing) to trolling (dragging lures and existential dread behind a boat). The economics? Wild salmon supports entire regional economies, tourism, and the occasional bear. In Canada, wild salmon brings in $109.9 million a year, which is almost enough to buy a Vancouver apartment.

Cost, Profit, and the Joy of Explaining Your Job at Parties

Here’s a handy chart to help you pretend you know what you’re talking about at your next dinner party:

Aspect

Farmed Salmon

Wild Salmon

Production Value

$735.2 million annually (Canada, 2011–2015)

$109.9 million (Skeena River watershed, 2004)

Infrastructure Costs

$26 billion needed to replace U.S. imports via land-based farms

Subsistence fishing contributes $77.8–160 million annually in Bristol Bay

Profitability

Requires $4.80/kg net profit to justify land-based CAPEX

Generates $414.7 million in regional expenditures annually

Farmed salmon is big business, but it’s a high-stakes game. Wild salmon is less about profit, more about tradition, pride, and the right to complain about “kids these days” ruining the rivers.

Health: Omega-3s vs. Mystery Additives

Wild salmon is the nutritional overachiever-more omega-3s, fewer toxins, and less likely to glow in the dark. Farmed salmon, on the other hand, contains five times the contaminants, plus a dash of antibiotics and a sprinkle of pesticides. But hey, it’s available year-round, and nothing says “modern convenience” like a fish that’s been raised on a diet of pellets and ennui.

The Verdict

If you want heart health, environmental bragging rights, and the moral superiority of a free-range fish, go wild. If you prefer your salmon cheap, plentiful, and with a side of existential crisis, farmed is for you. Either way, you’ll pay through the nose-and still have to explain to your dinner guests why their salmon tastes like a chemistry set.

Javier Clarkson, signing off. Next week: Why tofu is neither food nor friend, and how to survive a vegan barbecue with your dignity intact.

Data and facts based on the latest research into salmon farming, wild fisheries, and the economics of aquatic existentialism.

FOLLOW CANAMERICANEWS ACROSS ALL PLATFORMS

We're expanding our truth-telling mission! Stay connected with CanAmericaNews:

  • YouTube: Our newsletter articles now in video format

  • Facebook: Join our growing community discussions

  • X: Real-time updates and breaking news alerts

  • Instagram: Visual content and behind-the-scenes coverage

Simply search "CanAmericaNews" on your platform of choice.

Want more uncensored news? Forward this newsletter to a friend who values the truth.